Wednesday 31 July 2019

Ron Rosenbaum in conversation with Walter Schaber, “one of the last living survivors of the Weimar press wars.”

“What you have to remember, what people forget about that time, is that everyone was searching for a Heiland.”

“A Heiland?”

“Yes — healer, holy man. It was a time when you had healers, seers, prophets emerging all over the countryside. There were seers here, prophets there, all over.” He spoke of a certain Louis Hausser, a former champagne maker who set himself up as a prophet and called upon Germans to do penance for their sins, to heal themselves, to avert apocalyptic retribution. He spoke of a Joseph Wiesenberg in Berlin. “He claimed to heal people by laying hard white cheese on them,” and despite such dubious claims attracted a fanatic following of believers. “And then there was Hanussen the mystic and astrologer, who was in Munich with Hitler. They were all around, these people promising the messiah, all of them together created a mood from which Hitler could arise. An apocalyptic mood all over Germany. One Heiland after another, and after all the small Heilands came the big Heiland, Hitler.”

“You’re saying, then, that there was a pervasive appetite for some kind of apocalyptic figure, some kind of healer/messiah/saviour, a longing that  paved the way to accept Hitler, however strange and outlandish he seemed — in fact, because he was strange as he was?”

Yes, Schaber said, the very things that led conventional politicians and statesmen to underestimate and dismiss Hitler as outlandish and unsuitable, a hopeless outsider — that nicht natürlich strangeness, that alienness — were the very things that constituted the subterranean power of his appeal. Hitler’s other stigmata of strangeness, the apocalyptic fits, the trances, the occult, somnambulistic, mystic ravings, then — while they may have alienated some rational citizens — were perfectly attuned for the wider, deeper longing for a figure of higher irrationality, a Heiland, to rescue Germany. People who’d lost faith in conventional politics were looking for a political faith healer.

Something about this aspect of my conversation with Walter Schaber stayed with me for some time after I’d left Washington Heights. Something about the way he spoke of the longing for a Heiland led me to consider further the root in German of the word “Heiland,” holy man, healer: Heil. To consider further the deeper purpose behind the ritualized incantation of “Heil Hitler,” the all-purpose greeting, bond of solidarity, mass chant in the Hitler movement. To consider whether it might not have been designed deliberately to evoke the longing for a Heiland, for a healer, a holy man. Was that effect a deliberate creation, an example of Hitler’s conscious genius for manipulating mass psychology, or a fortuitous reflection of the preexistent unconscious longing for a Heiland it tapped into — or both? Was there always a deeper level than salutation, mere hailing, in the incantation “Heil Hitler”? A sense in which the speaker, the chanter, was imploring, urging the Führer: Heal Hitler. Heal Us Hitler. Heal Germany, Hitler. Less a salutation than a prayer.

When I asked Schaber for his reaction, as someone who lived through the awful period when “Heil Hitler” grew from the tribute of misfit sociopathic sycophants of a barbaric crank to a massive roar of near-religious national assent, he was skeptical at first. It struck him as a novel idea, “Heil Hitler” as “Heal, Hitler,” but after considering it, he told me, “I think there may be something to it.”

Explaining Hitler, Ron Rosenbaum

Thursday 11 July 2019

Leonard Cohen: the determinator, Details Magazine, July 1993

Leonard Cohen, the maestro of melancholy, answers questions on love, obsession, and despair

What’s the one thing men ought to know about women? A.B. (Berkeley, CA)
    They are deeply involved in a pattern of thought centered around the notion of commitment.

What’s the one thing women ought to know about men? T.M. (Worcester, MA)
    A man steadfastly refuses to eavesdrop on his conversation with himself.

Is there a difference between love and obsession? F.S. (Phoenix, AZ)
    It is the same difference between the Sermon on the Mount and the Crucifixion.

What do men really want? B.B. (Houston, TX)
    A square deal.

What would be the most appropriate thing for a guy to say to a girl after sex? J.H. (New York, NY)
    Thank you.

I am twenty-eight; I work and attend college. I have been single for three years and love women but have developed a strong attraction for Italian men only. I have repeated dreams about them. What should I do? J.G. (Los Angeles, CA)
    This habitual drift toward the trivial will continue to make you suffer.

Is it possible to be madly in love with more than one person at a time? M.B. (San Jose, Costa Rica)
    It is possible to be in love with more than one person at a time but not “madly in love.”

Is honesty always the best policy? G.W. (Hartford, CT)
    In my case, yes. In your case, rarely.

How can you tell if you’re in love? C.H. (Fort Lauderdale, FL)
    You dissolve your strategy for the other.

Why is having an orgasm so exhilarating? N.P. (Portland, OR)
    You stop thinking about yourself.

How can I remain friends with my former lover? R.A. (Chicago, IL)
    Move to another country.

Is it possible to achieve love without desire? S.O. (Washington, DC)
    Yes.

Are there any examples of good or healthy sexual relationships in the Bible? P.R. (Cleveland, OH)
    The patriarchs and their wives stand as shining examples of possible human marriages. The love of Jesus for Mary Magdalene continues to inspire me.

Is loneliness necessarily a sad thing? M.C. (Atlanta, GA)
    Yes, it is designed to be that way.

How long does it take to recover from a bad relationship? S.T. (Baltimore, MD)
    You never recover from a bad relationship.

I feel humiliated and exposed by my needs and my desires, even when they’re reciprocated. How can I deal with this? T.D. (London, England)
    You feel humiliated and confused anyway. Do not confuse the issue with your needs and desires.

Does there have to be democracy in sexual fantasies? I love tying up my lover, but I don’t want him to tie me up. C.H. (Middlebury, VT)
    You are already tied up.

Why do people marry? M.D. (Hudson, OH)
    I don’t know. Ask the man who owns one.